What are the three options?
A scaling consumer brand looking for CFO advisory usually chooses between three kinds of provider. Each does a different job well, so the right choice depends on what you need done. This page compares them as categories and names no firms.
- Large accounting and advisory firms. Firms that do audit, tax and statutory accounts, often with an advisory or transactions team alongside.
- CFO networks and franchises. Firms that match you with an individual fractional CFO from their pool, under the network's brand and process.
- Specialist independent fractional CFOs. One senior person, engaged directly, who focuses on a sector and does the work personally.
| Large accounting or advisory firm | CFO network or franchise | Specialist independent fractional CFO | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Scope | Audit, tax, statutory accounts, transaction support | Fractional CFO work, depending on the individual | Management accounts, forecasting, budgets, board reporting, raises and exits |
| Who does the work | A team, often led by a partner | The matched individual | The CFO personally |
| Sector depth | Broad, across many sectors | Depends on the individual matched | Deep in the chosen sectors |
| Pricing model | Often hourly or by scope | Varies by network | Often a fixed monthly fee |
| Typical client size | From small companies to large groups | Mostly startups and SMEs | Startups and SMEs up to around £40m |
| When it fits | Audit, tax, statutory work or a big transaction team | You want a matched CFO with a firm behind them | You want one senior person who knows your sector |
Who actually does the work?
This is the first question to ask any provider. At a large firm, the person who wins the work is often a partner, and the monthly work is done by a team that can change over time. In a CFO network, the work is done by the individual you are matched with. With a specialist independent fractional CFO, the person on the intro call is the person who builds your forecast and sits in your board meeting.
Neither model is wrong. A team gives you capacity and cover; one person gives you continuity, because the context stays with them.
How much consumer brand depth do you get?
Consumer brand finance has its own problems: contribution margin (what each sale leaves after product, delivery, fees and marketing) by channel and SKU, retailer terms and promotions, stock cash tied up months before it sells, and payouts from Shopify and Amazon to reconcile. A provider who has worked on those problems before will spot them faster.
Large firms cover many sectors and may have a consumer team. In a CFO network, depth depends on who you are matched with. A specialist fractional CFO usually works in a few sectors on purpose. Whichever you choose, ask for examples of channel margin, stock cash and board reporting work for brands like yours. For a fuller list of questions, see how to choose a CFO advisor for a UK consumer brand.
Fixed fee or hourly?
Pricing models differ more than prices. Larger firms often charge by the hour or by the scope of a piece of work. Networks vary. Specialist fractional CFOs often work on a fixed monthly fee, so you know the cost upfront and don't weigh every call against the clock.
Ask each provider how they charge, what is included each month and what counts as extra. We work on a fixed monthly fee, agreed upfront after an intro call. Strategic projects such as a raise or exit preparation are quoted as a fixed project fee.
When a large firm is the better choice
A large accounting or advisory firm is the better choice when the job is audit, tax or statutory work, or when a transaction needs a big team. A fractional CFO does not replace those.
- You need a statutory audit, or an investor or lender requires one.
- You need tax compliance, tax structuring or international tax work.
- A sale or acquisition needs formal due diligence with a team behind it.
- You run a complex group that needs many people on the accounts at once.
When a specialist fractional CFO is the better choice
A specialist fractional CFO is the better choice when you need senior judgement on margin, cash and the board, from one person who knows your sector. That usually means a brand growing fast, where finance has become the bottleneck.
- You don't know how much cash you will have in six months, or how much stock you can afford to buy.
- You can't see contribution margin by channel and SKU, so pricing and channel decisions are guesses.
- The board or investors want reporting you can't produce without losing days to it.
- You are preparing a raise or an exit and need the model and the numbers behind it.
Oro is an example of this model. William Smithwhite, an ex-Credit Suisse investment banker who has worked on over $20bn of M&A, equity and debt transactions, does the work personally, for consumer brands first, then consumer apps and energy companies. There are two monthly offers, Management Accounts and Fractional CFO, with raises and exit readiness scoped as Special Strategic Projects. See fractional CFO for consumer brands and our case studies.
Can you use both?
Yes, and many brands do. The accounting firm keeps the books compliant, files the year-end and tax, and runs the audit if you need one. The fractional CFO uses the same ledger to produce monthly management accounts, the forecast, the budget and the board pack.
Agree upfront who closes the month and who owns the forecast. For the general question, see fractional CFO vs accountant.