Fractional CFO vs finance manager.

A finance manager runs day-to-day finance; a fractional CFO sets the forecast, budget and board reporting. Which to hire first, and how the two work together.

By William Smithwhite, Fractional CFO (ex-Credit Suisse, MFin IE Business School). Last updated 10 November 2026.

What does a finance manager do?

A finance manager runs the day-to-day finance of the business. They handle accounts payable (paying suppliers), raise invoices and chase customers, do the bank and payment reconciliations and run the month-end close, which is the process of getting every transaction for the month into the books so the accounts are complete.

In a consumer brand that means matching Shopify, Amazon and retailer payments to the ledger, checking supplier invoices against stock received, and keeping payment runs on time. It is an in-house, hands-on role, usually full-time or close to it, and it keeps the numbers accurate and up to date.

What does a fractional CFO do?

A fractional CFO sets the direction of the finance function a few days a month. They build the forecast and the budget, model scenarios, write the board pack and lead raises. The job is to turn the finance manager's numbers into decisions.

At Oro, Management Accounts gives you the monthly accounts, KPIs and commentary. Fractional CFO adds a rolling 12-month P&L and cash forecast checked against actuals every month, the annual budget and variance, scenarios, the board pack and meetings, and investor reporting. For a consumer brand that means margin by channel and product and stock cash planned ahead; for a subscription app, store and Stripe payouts tied back to the accounts.

Where the roles overlap and where they differ

Both roles work from the same accounts, and both care about month-end being right. The finance manager owns the processing and the close. The CFO owns what the numbers mean and what to do about them.

Fractional CFO versus finance manager
Fractional CFOFinance manager
Day-to-day ownershipNo; reviews and sets standardsYes: invoices, payments, reconciliations
Month-end closeReviews the result and adds commentaryRuns it
ForecastingBuilds and owns the rolling forecastSupplies the actuals
BudgetsSets the budget and reports varianceTracks spend against it
Board and investor reportingWrites the board pack and attendsPrepares supporting schedules
Raising debt or equityLeads the model and the processSupports due diligence
Typical time commitmentA few days a monthFull-time or close to it

Which should you hire first?

Hire for the bottleneck. If the daily work is slipping, you need capacity first, and that is a finance manager. If the daily work is fine but you can't see ahead or make clear decisions, you need judgement first, and that is a fractional CFO. Use this checklist:

  • Invoices go out late, suppliers chase you, or reconciliations are months behind: finance manager first.
  • Month-end takes so long the numbers are out of date by the time you see them: finance manager first.
  • You don't know how much cash you will have in six months: fractional CFO first.
  • You can't say what a price change, a hire or a new channel does to margin: fractional CFO first.
  • A lender or investor wants a forecast and a board pack you don't have: fractional CFO first.
  • Board and investor reporting is eating your time every month: fractional CFO first.

If your accountant already handles the books well, a finance manager may not be needed yet. See fractional CFO vs accountant for that choice.

How a fractional CFO and finance manager work together

The finance manager closes the month; the CFO turns the close into management accounts, an updated forecast and a board pack. The CFO also sets the standards: what gets reconciled, how costs are coded and which KPIs are tracked, so the finance manager's work feeds straight into the reporting.

In the first month we build the infrastructure with the finance manager, learn the business and deliver the first management accounts pack and cash forecast. From the second month we add the more complex scenarios and KPIs, and by the third the investor reporting and board materials are in place. We did this as fractional CFO for a two-entity subscription app with a stretched finance function: year-end close and payment reconciliations, KPIs moved to a consolidated two-entity source, and the forecast and budgets rebuilt, giving one consolidated management accounts view and reconciled KPIs the team can trust. Read the case study.

Frequently asked questions

Can a fractional CFO manage our finance manager?
Yes. A fractional CFO can review the finance manager’s month-end, set the reporting standards and be the senior person they go to with questions. The finance manager runs the daily work; the CFO checks it, uses it and decides what the business should do next.
Do we need both?
Not always, and not at the same time. If the day-to-day work is under control, a fractional CFO on its own may be enough. If there is too much day-to-day work for the founder or the accountant, you need the finance manager’s capacity, and a CFO on top once decisions, the board or a raise need senior judgement.
What size of business needs a finance manager?
It depends on the volume of day-to-day finance work, not on revenue. When invoices, supplier payments, reconciliations and month-end take more time than the founder or the accountant can give, and things start to slip, it is time for a finance manager.
Can Management Accounts stand in for a finance manager?
Partly. Management Accounts covers the monthly accounts, KPIs and commentary, which is the reporting side of a finance manager’s job. It does not cover daily processing such as raising invoices, paying suppliers or chasing customers, which still needs a bookkeeper, an accountant or an in-house hire.